The charismatic TV personality asked his WWHL guest bartender John Hill, who also happens to be his musical theater star and radio host ex–to list five “Things Andy Should Do

Yes, Andy Cohen and ex John Hill did make a sex tape when they were together — but don’t expect it to see the light of day. Hill, 46, was the bartender during the Tuesday, January 7 episode of Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen.

At the end of Tuesday night’s (Jan. 7) episode of Watch What Happens Live, Hill — who is Cohen’s ex-boyfriend and trusty Radio Andy co-host — counted down the top five things the Bravo icon should do in 2025. “I’m already sweating,” Cohen joked before Hill began to read his list.

Andy Cohen has made a surprising sex tape confession. The Watch What Happens Live host, 56, was joined by his former flame, 46, John Hill, on Tuesday night's episode of his talk show. To the shock and amusement of fellow guests,